In an interview with MWorld, author and speaker John Izzo talked
about the important issues leaders must face to retain and inspire
the people they will need to achieve corporate competitive advantage.
MWORLD: You write about a "value shift." How is this shift
a reflection of the changing workforce?
Izzo: Over the last two decades much has been written about
how work has changed -- less security, more competition, faster
pace, and so on. While work has changed, our values about work have
also changed significantly. In fact, a new work ethic has emerged,
one that cuts across all three of the major generations in todayÿs
workforce -- baby boomers, generation X, and the net generation.
Any company wanting to win the best people or keep the ones they
have needs to be aware of how expectations about work and companies
have shifted. Keep in mind that our research shows these are not
�young person” shifts, the whole workforce has changed.
MWORLD: What will be the repercussions of this new workforce?
Izzo: What we have now is a more confident workforce, expecting
far more from work than security and making a living, people who
are far more willing to leave or make sacrifices to align their
values and their work. If we marry this new confidence and higher
expectations with the demographics, the talent crisis is going to
deepen significantly over the next decade. When the first baby boomers
start to retire early (60% say they will), companies are going to
be in for a �talent shock.” The pool of prospective employees will
turn into a puddle.
MWORLD: You mention six expectations within the workforce.
Could you briefly describe these and their importance to the different
segments of the workforce?
Izzo: In Values Shifts, we describe each of the six shifts,
the factors that influenced that shift, and how real companies are
and can respond to those shifts.
The first shift is the expectation for balance and synergy. We
have gone from a time when people expected to have to organize their
life around work to the expectation that the workplace help them
with their personal life. Balance is now the #1 issue for working
women and in the top five for working men. In fact, 26% of us say
we would gladly give up 20% of our salary for more time off. A survey
of union members in Canada found 71% of them saying their top priority
now for negotiations is not more hours but less with more flexibility.
There is a revolution happening. We want flex hours, part-time work,
sabbaticals, help with day care, a personal trainer on site. And
companies that respond to this shift in innovative ways -- especially
for working women -- will achieve amazing increases in retention.
This first expectation cuts across all generations but is felt differently.
But the bottom line is an awful lot of us now want to get out of
the rat race.
The second shift is the expectation for community. In our book
we show that as little as 25 years ago very few of us found friendships
at work. In fact, many baby boomers were taught not to mix work
and play. Now the workplace has become a major source for friendship
and community. For example, there are a growing number of studies
showing that employees are far more loyal and productive when they
perceive that their manager takes an interest in their personal
lives and when they have personal friends at work. We even suggest
that many innovative companies are creating what we refer to as
�new company towns” where the workplace becomes the hub of friendship,
fun, and community. We have less leisure time and we are more mobile
so work now has to meet needs that used to get met after work. This
shift is most pronounced among younger workers, generations x and
y.
The third shift is the expectation for work to serve a noble cause.
I consider this to be one of the more fascinating shifts we discovered.
In fact, a survey of graduating college students in the US found
86% of them saying theyÿd rather make enough money and make a �difference”
in their careers than make lots of money and not make a �difference.”
In our own retention assessments with companies, we hear this consistently.
Software programmers say the technology they are working on is �not
changing the world” and salespeople say �I donÿt believe in our
products or the company.” This desire for noble cause gets translated
in various ways -- the desire to volunteer on company time, to hear
about how the products a company makes impact real people, and to
work at a place where values are real and lived up to. In fact,
over the last decade the factors employees use to judge an enterprise
have changed. Size and stability used to be the top factors and
social responsibility was not even on the list. Now in a short ten
years it is #4 and size is losing ground.
MWORLD: What is the fourth?
Izzo: Itÿs the expectation for growth and development. Our
research found that thirty years ago even the most highly paid professionals
in our society saw work as primarily a way to make a living. If
the work was also interesting and challenging, it was a nice bonus.
Now two out of three of us say work is more a form of our self-identity;
the first question we are asked when we meet someone is, �What do
you do?” Exciting and interesting work is now the #1 reason why
professionals say they turned down a new job and one of the best
predictors of a committed employee is that they feel they are learning
and growing. The interesting thing is that this shift is not just
about being employable, it is about wanting and expecting work to
be interesting.
The fifth shift is the expectation for partnership. Todayÿs workforce
has moved way beyond empowerment in terms of what they expect from
an employer. Over 50% of women and over 70% of men have actively
thought about starting their own business in the last three years,
and the #1 career net generation workers want to pursue is that
of entrepreneur. As a result of far flung factors such as the Internet,
more permissive parenting, the falling of the Berlin wall, and smaller
sibling groups, todayÿs workers want a workplace with little hierarchy,
few rules (especially ones that make no sense to them), and a leadership
that listens to them in a profoundly new way. In the book, we give
a great many examples of how companies are responding to this desire
for partnership. My favorite is AES, a worldwide power company with
48,000 employees, that set a goal to eliminate every formal approval
process within five years. In other words, letÿs make it so that
no one has to ask permission for anything beyond their own team.
This is the kind of radical thinking that will be required. This
shift is also most pronounced among the youngest employees who feel
if you can tell the president of Russia he is crazy now and not
be arrested you certainly ought to be able to challenge your boss,
or your managerÿs boss without fear.
MWORLD: And the final expectation isž.
Izzo: Trust. Trust in organizations and institutions, especially
large ones, has been steadily declining over the last decade. In
one survey 64% of employees said that management routinely fails
to tell the truth and 43% believe their managers cheat and lie.
A survey of executives showed that only 15% believed that �trust”
was improving in their firms, and 75% said it was declining. But
amidst all this skepticism, people have a deep desire for an organization
where truth is told, where a set of values are more than a piece
of paper, where straight talk about whatÿs happening is the norm.
Any company or managers who can demonstrate this trustworthiness
will have a big leg up on other employers.
MWORLD: Of the six expectations, is there one more important
than the rest? If so, which is it?
Izzo: All of the shifts are critical. Together, they form
a tapestry of how we have come to define a great place to work.
But if I had to choose only one it would be the desire for partnership.
The four most powerful words for engaging todayÿs workforce are:
What do you think? People want to be consulted and have a say. The
expectation for balance is also very pervasive. Time and flexibility
are now more valuable to many of us than money. So companies that
help people go in and out of work to focus on other things that
are important to them will achieve significant levels of loyalty.
MWORLD: Let's talk about the new work ethic. How does that
tie into the six expectations you have identified?
Izzo: The new work ethic goes something like this: We expect
more from work than we ever have. We expect it to be interesting,
we expect to be treated like partners, we expect it to be about
more than profits, and meet our need for community. Most of all,
we want greater flexibility so that we can work in bursts of time
and then take time off from it. I think in the future you will see
a lot more 35 year olds retiring and then coming back to work many
times after that. MWORLD: All right. We -- meaning the workforce
-- want more from work. What aspects of the business will this impact?
Izzo: Now that work is as much about who we are as a way
to make a living, there will be significant pressure on organizations
to create meaning for people. So companies will find it harder to
keep people for a long time. To keep them, given that work has become
a psychic part of peopleÿs lives, companies will have to hold people
with looser reigns. I suggest that my clients think about their
employees now like universities think about alumni. Keep in touch
with former employees, ask them to refer other people, and understand
that rather than work with you for a lifetime they may work for
you several times in their life but do other things in between.
MWORLD: So there will be greater retention issues to address?
Izzo: Employee retention will become one of the major issues
for a long time and these shifting values will raise the bar on
what it will take to attract and keep people. Even more fundamentally,
these shifts will mean more part-time work, more people going in
and out of workplaces, and a growing focus for managers at creating
a deep sense of community for people.
MWORLD: Do you have a corporate case that you can share
with us that reflects the value shift?
Izzo: My favorite example is AES, one of the worldÿs largest
power companies. They set a goal of creating �the most fun work
environment since the beginning of the industrial revolution.” They
have focused on creating a place focused on social responsibility,
where people are treated like partners, with no set amount of vacation
time, and where hierarchy is a distant memory. Companies like them
are at the forefront of where the world of work is going. At a more
micro level, there is Dawson Personnel Systems that worked out a
deal with their sales and back office people to have more time off
for more productivity. Sales and productivity soared and people
got more time off. Then there is TD Industries, a mechanical engineering
and construction firm in Dallas with a turnover rate of 15% with
an industry average of 100%. They have made listening a religion
and have regular time devoted simply to hear what is on employeesÿ
minds. They treat their former employees like alumni, and by keeping
in touch with them have won many of them back. I could go on, but
here is the point: There is an A-team out there emerging and when
the pool of potential workers turns into a puddle, your organization
better be on the A-team.
MWORLD: You researched a considerable number of companies
to identify the changes in values. Would you describe that research?
Izzo: I first suspected that there was a new work ethic
when I would present to leaders about how �net” generation workers
were different. To my surprise the baby boomers would come up to
me and tell me that they wanted the same things the �young” workers
wanted. So we put together a team of researchers and said, �Get
us everything you can find on our desires and values towards work
over the last thirty years.” When we put all of that research together,
the six shifts, what we call the new work ethic, was apparent. Then
we sent that same team out and said, �Find us examples of how companies
are responding to those shifts and changing practices.” What we
discovered were hundreds of great examples of what people were doing.
At the same time we had worked with over 300 companies ourselves
and could access examples from our clients. Finally, we chose six
companies that we felt exemplified some of these shifts and did
features on them. Readers have said the examples are very helpful.
MWORLD: To our readers, if there was one major thing that
they could do to change their company's ability to compete for talent
in the workplace, what would you propose?
Izzo: First and foremost, become better students of what
people want from work. The old lexicon is becoming obsolete. Study
the shifts and be honest about how you are doing as a leader and
as an organization. In terms of practical ideas, here is my a-list: